Posted by Stuart Montgomery at 3:22 pm
Panel: AJAX or Flash: What’s Right for You?
3/11
Sun
- Panel
- Jonathan Boutelle, CEO of SlideShare
- SlideShare is built to be the YouTube of PowerPoint
- Users upload ppt files after a conference and get a flash-version compiled that is share
- and embed-able worldwide
- The app uses both Flash and AJAX integrally
- 1- Play the field
- You don’t have to choose either AJAX or Flash
- You might even need both tools
- Bottom line: pick the best tool for the job, don’t let biases or hype decide which tool you use
- 2- Keep Flash on a leash
- Full-screen Flash is a no-no
- People don’t like 100% flash sites over time
- Use “Flash nuggets”
- A less-thought of disadvantage is that search-engines can’t spider Flash apps
- Flash is bulkier and takes a little longer to load
- Instead of the bulk of Flash, use the power of HTML already given to us over time
- 3- Cheap Tricks
- Things like in-place editing, attention control, in-page messaging to user, tabs
- In-place editing
- Show people data in a read-only fashion, with small controls to change the data
- When they click to edit, change the read-only data to text fields, or some analogous field for your type of data.
- When done editing change back to read-only and save behind the scenes using AJAX
- Attention control
- Show that “something happened” behind the scenes
- 4- Flash graphic goodies
- Flash is the best for things like embedding fonts, heavier animation, vector graphics, etc.
- 5- Flash multimedia
- 6- Widgets
- Choosing the Flash or JS version of a widget depends on what effect on the page you want to have
- Flash tends to be more noticeable, JS tends to integrate into the page better
- 7- Cool Flash features that aren’t useful
- Sockets
- more pro’s choose an HTTP hack to keep the session open. Used by GTalk and Meebo
- Local Data Objects
- not a lot of people using them, a cookie-like client storage system
- FLEX
- mostly outputs full-screen Flash application replacements
Check out Jonathan’s slides on his SlideShare.


Comments (1)
Hey,
Thanks for blogging this!
FYI, have uploaded the slides to slideshare, and put most of the text from my talk there as well.
http://www.slideshare.net/jboutelle/ajax-vs-flash-whats-right-for-you
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.